Among the wired wearable breast pumps, the Momcozy V1 and Elvie Stride are two great options. The first is good for an affordable price while the latter stands out for its app control. Momcocy V1 vs Elvie Stride, which one do you prefer?
Both are hospital-grade breast pumps.
Here in this comparison post for Momcozy V1 vs Elive Stride, we also want to show you what are the similarities and differences between them. If you’re still hesitant to choose which one, Momcozy V1 or Elvie Stride, check this post before making the final purchase.
My Choice – Momcozy V1
At first, Momcozy V1 was more affordable in price, selling at $199.99. So it’s more suitable if you have a limited budget for a hospital-grade breast pump.
The Elvie Stride is priced at $269.99, currently discounted to $179.99 for summer sale. It also features hospital-grade suction power with a little higher suction strength (300 mmHg) than Momcozy V1 (290 mmHg).
The Elvie Stride also has a longer battery life, lasting up to 180 minutes per full charge compared to the 150 minutes of the Momcozy V1. Additionally, the Elvie Stride is app-controlled, allowing for adjusting the levels for comfortable pumping.
You can also recall the last settings via the app. However, the app’s control lacks the versatility of Elive Pump, which is more expensive than Stride.
The app control should not be the primary reason you get Elvie Stride. The newer Momcozy M9 (also called Mobile Flow) also has the ‘smart’ feature but cheaper, at $269.99, the same price as the Elive Stride but providing more great features like more customization freedom, wireless design, and a carry bag for better portability.
Check the Momcozy V1 review.
Check the Elvie Stride review.
Momcozy V1 vs Elvie Stride – Similarity and Difference
| Breast Pump | Momcozy V1 | Elvie Stride |
|---|---|---|
| Suction Strength | 290 mmHg | 300 mmHg |
| Modes | Three | Two |
| Levels | 9 | 10 |
Similarities:
- Both are wired wearable breast pumps.
- Both offer hospital-grade suction strength.
- Both are designed to be hands-free.
- Both have similar collection cup capacities of 5 oz.
Differences:
- Suction strength: 290 mmHg for Momcozy V1 vs. 300 mmHg for Elvie Stride.
- Battery life: 150 minutes for Momcozy V1 vs. 180 minutes for Elvie Stride.
- Weight: Momcozy V1 is slightly lighter overall but has a bulkier pump motor.
- Control method: Momcozy V1 has an LED screen, while Elvie Stride is app-controlled.
The Momcozy V1 and Elvie Stride share several similarities. Both are hands-free wearable breast pumps with hospital-grade suction strength. Additionally, both models have collection cup capacities of 5 oz, which is good enough for moms with average milk production.
However, the differences between the two are still noticeable. The Momcozy V1 has a suction strength of 290 mmHg, while the Elvie Stride offers a slightly higher strength of 300 mmHg.
In terms of weight, the Momcozy V1 is slightly lighter overall, but its pump motor is bulkier, making it less portable than the Elvie Stride even though it packs with a carry bag. The Elvie Stride’s pump motor is more compact and lightweight, making it easier to carry around.
Battery life is another key difference, with the Momcozy V1 lasting up to 150 minutes per charge compared to the Elvie Stride’s 180 minutes. That’s right equal to one 30-minute pumping session.
Control methods also differ, as the Momcozy V1 uses an LED screen for operation and monitoring, whereas the Elvie Stride is app-controlled, allowing you to adjust the levels or apply the settings for the last pumps.
The Elive Stride is more appealing to young modern moms who can’t live without their iPhones :).
Price
Selling at $199.99, the Momcozy V1 is a budget-friendly wearable breast pump for moms who are looking for a reliable breast pump without breaking the bank.
The Elvie Stride is priced higher at $269.99. However, it is currently discounted to $179.99 for the summer sale, which makes it even more competitive with the Momcozy V1.
This price drop for the Elvie Stride significantly enhances its value proposition, especially considering its compact pump motor, app control, and slightly higher suction strength.
However, if it’s back to the normal listing price of $269.99, I won’t recommend the Elive Stride. The app control and suction strength gap are not worth the price difference.
If you’re in favor of its portability, the Momcozy V2 can compete with the Elive Stride at this point.
Pump Design: Momcozy V1 vs Elvie Stride
The difference in pump design for Momcozy V1 vs Elive Stride lies mainly in the pump motor.
The Momcozy V1 features a bulkier pump motor, which may be less convenient for on-the-go use. The pump motor can’t be carried in the small pockets but needs you to carry it in hand when pumping or put it in big pockets. However, its included carry bag compensates for its overall performance in portability.
The Elvie Stride’s pump motor is more compact and lightweight, designed in a long bar shape – more similar to the Momcozy V2’s, that can easily fit into a pocket, making it highly portable.
Both breast pumps come with collection cups at the same capacity of up to 5 oz, but the weights are different. The Momcozy V1’s collection cup weighs 120g, while the Elvie Stride’s cups weigh 150g each.
When it comes to pump parts, the Momcozy V1 includes various components such as collection cups, breast shields, and the pump motor. The Elvie Stride, however, offers a more streamlined design with fewer parts, making it easier to assemble and clean. You only need to wash four parts for Elive Stride and the Momcozy V1 has five parts to clean.
Flange Design
Both the Momcozy V1 and Elive Stride are friendly for most small and large breast moms.
The Momcozy V1 comes in two flange sizes – 24mm and 27mm, along with multiple flange inserts including 15mm, 17mm, 19mm, and 21mm. Even if you have different breasts on both sides – this case is very common among most moms after breastfeeding, you can always find the best-fit flange size or insert.
The better point about Momcozy V1 is the double-sealed, skin-friendly flange design, which provides a comfortable and secure fit, enhancing the pumping experience and reducing milk leakage.
The Elvie Stride, on the other hand, is equipped with one 24-mm breast shield. But it includes one additional flange insert, ranging from 15mm to 28mm. This wider range of flange sizes offers more options for moms to find their perfect fit.
It’s a pity that Elvie Stride does not have any new technique applied to the flange design for a better seal. However, we never meet a milk leak situation using Elive Stride. No moms complain about this point across the web.
The Momcozy V1 outperforms slightly over the Elive Stride but is not the leading factor for choosing between these two wearable breast pumps.
Pump Performance: Momcozy V1 vs Elvie Stride
| Breast Pump | Momcozy V1 | Elvie Stride |
|---|---|---|
| Suction Strength | 290 mmHg | 300 mmHg |
| Modes | Three | Two |
| Levels | 9 | 10 |
How you can adjust the pumping settings for a breast pump decides the comfort and efficiency.
The pump performance is generally related to maximum suction strength, modes, and adjustable levels.
The Momcozy V1 offers three modes: Stimulation, Expression, and Mixed, with a suction strength of 290 mmHg and nine levels for each mode. It provides a variety of customizations for you to find the most comfortable and efficient settings.
The Elive Stride has one fewer mode. It supports only Stimulation and Expression but provides more levels for adjustment – 10 levels for each mode. You can choose the mode and the level in the app.
The suction strength of the Elvie Stride is slightly more powerful than that of the Momcozy V1, 300 mmHg vs 290 mmHg. But both boast that they’re hospital-grade breast pumps.
Due to individual conditions, some moms complain that Elvie Stride can’t help empty the milk, resulting in clogged ducts.
My experience is that using a lactation message before starting the Stimulation mode and staying in this mode for a bit longer than usual, for example, you stimulate your breast and nipple for 3 minutes before but now extend it to 4 or 5 minutes.
Battery Life and Charge
Battery life plays an important role for wearable breast pumps especially if you prefer their portability.
The Momcozy V1 can be used for 150 minutes per full charge, which is sufficient for 5-6 pumping sessions throughout the day. That’s good for most working moms who need to pump at the office or when moving around.
The Elive Stride performs better in battery life. It allows for 180 minutes of continuous use per full charge. That’s one pumping session longer than the Momcozy V1. If you have average milk production and pump 5-6 times one day, both can satisfy your needs.
Both pumps take around 120 minutes to fully charge, just similar to most electric breast pumps on the market. I don’t care about the charging time much because you can always charge them at night when the pump is not in use or find a two-hour gap between pumping sessions during the day.
For me, the battery life difference is not the deciding factor in choosing Momcozy V1 vs Elvie Stride. Is this important to you? Leave a comment below.
Portability
Portability is a key consideration for many moms when choosing a wearable breast pump. Both the Momcozy V1 and Elvie Stride are portable breast pumps.
The V1 weighs 520g overall. It’s relatively lightweight. The pump motor design decreases its performance in portability, a bit bulky, making it less convenient to carry in small pockets.
The Elvie Stride is a bit heavier, weighing 540g overall, but its pump motor is more lightweight and compact. Its long bar-shaped pump motor can easily fit into a pocket, making it highly portable and ideal for moms who need to move around while pumping.
However, it does not include a carry bag with the default price. You’ll either need to buy a carry bag or upgrade to the Elive Stride Plus, which is more expensive ($319.99) with additional accessories like three bags and 1 neck strap.
The Momcozy V1 includes a carry bag, making it more convenient and portable for moms on the go. You can always store the breast pumps in the bag and take it to the office or for travel.
App-controlled or not?
The control interface of a breast pump can greatly impact its usability.
The Momcozy V1 features a large LED screen that allows you to easily read necessary information such as pumping status (modes and levels) and battery remaining. This clear and straightforward interface makes the Momcozy V1 user-friendly and easy to operate.
On the other hand, the Elvie Stride is app-controlled, offering a more modern and customizable experience.
The app lets you control the pump remotely and adjust settings for optimal comfort and efficiency. However, it lacks advanced settings like live milk monitoring and customizable pumping.
Which way do you prefer?
Warranty
The Momcozy V1 comes with a one-year warranty, providing a standard level of protection for the product. This warranty covers any manufacturing defects or issues that may arise during regular use.
The Elvie Stride, on the other hand, offers a more generous two-year warranty. This extended warranty period provides additional peace of mind for mothers, ensuring that they are covered for a longer duration in case of any problems or defects with the pump.
The Verdict
In summary, both the Momcozy V1 and Elvie Stride have their own unique advantages and disadvantages.
The Momcozy V1 is more affordable and offers a strong suction strength to suit most moms, making it a reliable and budget-friendly option. Its LED screen provides a clear and straightforward control interface, and its double-sealed flange design ensures a comfortable and secure fit.
The Elvie Stride, however, stands out with its higher suction strength, longer battery life, and more compact and lightweight design. Its app-controlled functionality offers greater remote control and smart feeling and the extended two-year warranty provides added peace of mind.
Additionally, the current summer sale discount makes the Elvie Stride a highly competitive option.
